MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Research Associates
    • Justin Beaumont
    • Roland Boer
    • Robert Bosco
    • Christopher Craig Brittain
    • Çağdaş Dedeoğlu
    • Timothy Fitzgerald
    • George Gonzalez
    • Warren S. Goldstein
    • Marsha Hewitt
    • Darlene Juschka
    • Rebekka King
    • George Lundskow
    • Seyed Javad Miri
    • Matthew Del Nevo
    • Kenneth MacKendrick
    • Craig Martin
    • Andrew McKinnon
    • Sarah M. Pike
    • Jean-Pierre Reed
    • Dana Sawchuk
    • Rudolf J. Siebert
    • Paul-François Tremlett
  • Journal
  • Book Series
  • Listserve
  • Blog
  • Meetings
  • Readings
    • The Left Hegelians
    • Marx and Engels
    • The Social Democrats
    • Friedrich Nietzsche
    • Max Weber
    • Ernst Troeltsch
    • Sigmund Freud
    • The Frankfurt School
      • Walter Benjamin
      • Ernst Bloch
      • Theodor W. Adorno
      • Max Horkheimer
      • Erich Fromm
      • Leo Löwenthal
      • Jürgen Habermas
    • Post-Structuralism
      • Michel Foucault
      • Jacques Derrida
    • Critical Theory of Religion
    • Class Analysis of Religion
    • Critical Feminist Studies in Religion
    • Queer Studies and Religion
  • Links
    • Academic Associations
      • American Academy of Religion
      • Asociación de Cientistas Sociales de la Religión del Mercosur
      • Association for Critical Sociology
      • Association for the Sociology of Religion
      • The Critical Religion Association
      • Ernst Bloch Assoziation
      • International Society for the Sociology of Religion
      • International Walter Benjamin Society
      • North American Association for the Study of Religion
      • Radical Philosophy Association
      • Religious Research Association
      • Society for Biblical Literature
      • Society for the Scientific Study of Religion
    • Sections
      • AAA Society for the Anthropology of Religion
      • APA Society for the Psychology of Religion & Spirituality
      • BSA Sociology of Religion Study Group
      • ASA Section on Marxist Sociology
      • ISA RC22 Sociology of Religion
      • ASA Section on the Sociology of Religion
    • Journals
      • A-J
        • The Bible and Critical Theory
        • Comparative Islamic Studies
        • Constellations
        • Crisis and Critique
        • Critical Horizons
        • Culture and Religion
        • Historical Materialism
        • Implicit Religion
        • Islamic Perspective Journal
        • Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
        • Journal of the American Academy of Religion
        • Journal of Contemporary Religion
      • K-Z
        • Method and Theory in the Study of Religion
        • Middle East Studies Online Journal
        • New German Critique
        • Philosophy and Social Criticism
        • Religion Compass
        • Review of Religious Research
        • Social Compass
        • Sociology of Religion
        • Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses
        • Telos
        • Thesis Eleven
        • Theory, Culture & Society
    • Book Series
      • Insurrections: Critical Studies in Religion, Politics, and Culture
      • Studies in Critical Research on Religion
      • Studies in Religion and Critical Thought
    • Foundations and Trusts
      • Pew Religion and Public Life
      • Lilly Endowment - Religion
      • John Templeton Foundation
    • Research Institutes and Centers
      • Center for Religions and Institutions in Post-Secular Society
      • Erich Fromm Institut Tübingen
      • Critical Religion Research Group
      • Ernst Bloch Zentrum
      • Institut für Sozialforschung
      • Institute for Critical Theory
    • Graduate Programs
      • Global Center for Advanced Studies
      • History and Critical Theories of Religion - Vanderbilt University
      • Critical Religion - University of Sterling
    • Archives
      • Adorno Archiv
      • Max Horkheimer Archive
      • Nachlass Leo Löwenthal
    • Websites
      • Critical Theory of Religion and Society
      • E-International Relations
      • Herbert Marcuse Homepage
      • Marxismo Critico
      • Marxist Internet Archive
      • Mute
      • Public Theology
      • Radicalisation Research
      • Sociology of Religion Resources
      • Walter Benjamin Research Syndicate
    • Blogs
      • Being and Lime (Chris Brittain)
      • Failed Messiah
      • Stalin's Moustache (Roland Boer)
      • The Religion Factor
    • Museums
      • Wilhelm Reich Museum
    • Newsletters
      • Religion Watch
  • Contact
The Center for Critical Research on ReligionThe Center for Critical Research on Religion


"the premise of all criticism"

www.criticaltheoryofreligion.org
MENUMENU
  • Home
  • Research Associates
    • Justin Beaumont
    • Roland Boer
    • Robert Bosco
    • Christopher Craig Brittain
    • Çağdaş Dedeoğlu
    • Timothy Fitzgerald
    • George Gonzalez
    • Warren S. Goldstein
    • Marsha Hewitt
    • Darlene Juschka
    • Rebekka King
    • George Lundskow
    • Seyed Javad Miri
    • Matthew Del Nevo
    • Kenneth MacKendrick
    • Craig Martin
    • Andrew McKinnon
    • Sarah M. Pike
    • Jean-Pierre Reed
    • Dana Sawchuk
    • Rudolf J. Siebert
    • Paul-François Tremlett
  • Journal
  • Book Series
  • Listserve
  • Blog
  • Meetings
  • Readings
    • The Left Hegelians
    • Marx and Engels
    • The Social Democrats
    • Friedrich Nietzsche
    • Max Weber
    • Ernst Troeltsch
    • Sigmund Freud
    • The Frankfurt School
      • Walter Benjamin
      • Ernst Bloch
      • Theodor W. Adorno
      • Max Horkheimer
      • Erich Fromm
      • Leo Löwenthal
      • Jürgen Habermas
    • Post-Structuralism
      • Michel Foucault
      • Jacques Derrida
    • Critical Theory of Religion
    • Class Analysis of Religion
    • Critical Feminist Studies in Religion
    • Queer Studies and Religion
  • Links
    • Academic Associations
      • American Academy of Religion
      • Asociación de Cientistas Sociales de la Religión del Mercosur
      • Association for Critical Sociology
      • Association for the Sociology of Religion
      • The Critical Religion Association
      • Ernst Bloch Assoziation
      • International Society for the Sociology of Religion
      • International Walter Benjamin Society
      • North American Association for the Study of Religion
      • Radical Philosophy Association
      • Religious Research Association
      • Society for Biblical Literature
      • Society for the Scientific Study of Religion
    • Sections
      • AAA Society for the Anthropology of Religion
      • APA Society for the Psychology of Religion & Spirituality
      • BSA Sociology of Religion Study Group
      • ASA Section on Marxist Sociology
      • ISA RC22 Sociology of Religion
      • ASA Section on the Sociology of Religion
    • Journals
      • A-J
        • The Bible and Critical Theory
        • Comparative Islamic Studies
        • Constellations
        • Crisis and Critique
        • Critical Horizons
        • Culture and Religion
        • Historical Materialism
        • Implicit Religion
        • Islamic Perspective Journal
        • Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion
        • Journal of the American Academy of Religion
        • Journal of Contemporary Religion
      • K-Z
        • Method and Theory in the Study of Religion
        • Middle East Studies Online Journal
        • New German Critique
        • Philosophy and Social Criticism
        • Religion Compass
        • Review of Religious Research
        • Social Compass
        • Sociology of Religion
        • Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses
        • Telos
        • Thesis Eleven
        • Theory, Culture & Society
    • Book Series
      • Insurrections: Critical Studies in Religion, Politics, and Culture
      • Studies in Critical Research on Religion
      • Studies in Religion and Critical Thought
    • Foundations and Trusts
      • Pew Religion and Public Life
      • Lilly Endowment - Religion
      • John Templeton Foundation
    • Research Institutes and Centers
      • Center for Religions and Institutions in Post-Secular Society
      • Erich Fromm Institut Tübingen
      • Critical Religion Research Group
      • Ernst Bloch Zentrum
      • Institut für Sozialforschung
      • Institute for Critical Theory
    • Graduate Programs
      • Global Center for Advanced Studies
      • History and Critical Theories of Religion - Vanderbilt University
      • Critical Religion - University of Sterling
    • Archives
      • Adorno Archiv
      • Max Horkheimer Archive
      • Nachlass Leo Löwenthal
    • Websites
      • Critical Theory of Religion and Society
      • E-International Relations
      • Herbert Marcuse Homepage
      • Marxismo Critico
      • Marxist Internet Archive
      • Mute
      • Public Theology
      • Radicalisation Research
      • Sociology of Religion Resources
      • Walter Benjamin Research Syndicate
    • Blogs
      • Being and Lime (Chris Brittain)
      • Failed Messiah
      • Stalin's Moustache (Roland Boer)
      • The Religion Factor
    • Museums
      • Wilhelm Reich Museum
    • Newsletters
      • Religion Watch
  • Contact

“Toward a Critical Sociology of Religion”

September 16, 2013 Posted by admin Critical Research on Religion

Critical Research on Religion
at the 75th Annual Meeting of the
Association for the Sociology of Religion,
11th August 2013

CRR2-2

The SAGE journal Critical Research on Religion (CRR) sponsored a session at the 75th Annual Meeting of the Association for the Sociology of Religion (ASR), which was held at the Doubletree Metropolitan Hotel in New York. Organized and convened by Rhys Williams (Loyola University of Chicago), the title of the session was “Toward a Critical Sociology of Religion.” Professor Williams is past present of the ASR, the SSSR (Society for the Scientific Study of Religion), and was editor of the Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion (JSSR), the highest ranked journal in the sociology of religion, for five years. Participants on the panel were Mary Jo Neitz (University of Missouri, Columbia), Todd Fuist (Western Washington University), and Courtney Ann Arby (Loyola University of Chicago). All of the participants were contributors to the special issue, guest edited by Professor Williams, entitled “Possibilities in the Critical Sociology of Religion” (Volume 1, Issue 2, August 2013).

L-R) Courtney Ann Irby, Todd Fuist, Mary Jo Neitz, and Rhys Williams present at the ASR meeting 2013

L-R) Courtney Ann Irby, Todd Fuist, Mary Jo Neitz, and Rhys Williams present at the ASR meeting 2013

Rhys Williams introduced the three panelists and provided an explanation behind the journal and the special issue. He pointed out that CRR can bridge the gap between the social sciences and humanities, bringing the sociology of religion in conversation with religious studies. He explained that a critical sociology of religion should be methodologically eclectic and not just confined to critical theory. Agreeing with the findings of a recent article by David Smilde (posted on the Immanent Frame blog of the Social Science Research Council), he argued that too much of recent sociology of religion has only focused on the positive aspects of religion without focusing on the negative.

Mary Jo Neitz gave a talk on her article in the special issue of CRR entitled “Insiders, Outsiders, Advocates and Apostates and the Religions They Study: Location and the Sociology of Religion.” Using feminist standpoint theory as her basis, she argued one must take into consideration the position of the researcher in relationship to that of the researched. Agreeing with the arguments made in the volume edited by Bender, Cadge, Levitt, Smilde (Religion on the Edge, Oxford University Press, 2012), too much research in the sociology of religion has been written by mainstream American Protestants who write about mainstream American Protestantism. Neitz presented her location matrix which takes into consideration whether both the researcher and researched are part of the dominant culture or a marginal culture and whether they are an insider (adherent) or outsider (not an adherent). As a solution to this problematic, Neitz called for “more reflexivity in all of our work.”

Todd Fuist presented the article that he coauthored with Thomas J. Josephsohn (Loyola University of Chicago) entitled “Lines that Matter, Lines that Don’t: Religion, Boundaries, and the Meaning of Difference.” This was based on interview data of members of a number of different denominations that came out of their doctorial dissertations. In this article, they discuss religious boundaries- whether they are permeable or impermeable, relevant or irrelevant. Religious differences may be more or less relevant and the boundaries between people of different religious groups may be more or less permeable. This will shape the attitudes that people of different religious background have to each other.

Finally, Courtney Ann Irby discussed her article entitled “Evangelical Elites and Young Adults Negotiating the Disrupted Landscape of Christian Relationships.” Irby’s research was based upon interviews she conducted with students at Christian evangelical colleges. Using as her baseline a number of books that were written by Christian evangelical elites, she asked students about their attitudes toward courtship, dating, and hooking up. While she found that most students had never read these books, they were indirectly influenced by them through their parents. Although the students did not embrace the ideal of courtship advocated by these books, this nevertheless did play a role in their attitudes toward dating and even more so to casual hooking up.

In the discussion, the authors were asked whether they had a particular theoretical frame that guided their analysis. While a few of the authors identified particular theories by which they were influenced, they all concurred that their research was inductive and not deductive- that rather than theory guiding their research they developed theories out of their research. These theories are implicitly critical and thus expand our understanding of the possibilities of a critical sociology of religion.

Sign up for Critical Research on Religion’s free trial here and access the August Special Issue online here.

Warren S. Goldstein, co-editor, Critical Research on Religion

Tags: critical sociology of religion
Share
0

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Send Message
Prev Next